The Topline: Voters give green light on “red flag” gun law

Massachusetts House Speaker Robert DeLeo announced this week the House would take up the so-called “red flag” gun safety bill. The move ended months of speculation and growing pressure from outside the building. The proposed legislation would “allow a judge to temporarily seize guns from someone who might pose a danger to themselves and others.”

Eight states already have similar laws on the books, and some 20 more are considering them. Since the school shooting in Parkland, Florida in February, Florida itself and Maryland -- like Massachusetts, a blue state with a popular Republican governor -- have passed their own.

As has often been true on other issues in recent years, Massachusetts voters are way ahead of the state legislature. Our March WBUR poll found 89 percent of voters statewide approve of the proposed change. Massachusetts voters also approve of a variety of other tougher gun laws not currently being debated. Majorities also support raising the age to purchase a firearm to 21, banning high capacity magazines, and even banning semi-automatic rifles.

wbur gun law img.png

Even so, a red flag law is a significant step, and a break from an all too familiar pattern. After many mass shootings, there is an initial outburst of shock and outrage, but it subsides but before any action is taken. The conversation around guns since Parkland has been a bit more durable, although even this more sustained bump is showing signs of dropping off.

huffpost gun topline.png

Much of the credit must go to students in the state. The Parkland survivors have drawn attention nationally, but students across Massachusetts have been marching, too. DeLeo gave credit where due, pointing to student protestors as a key force behind the push for the bill and holding the announcement at a school. Students have been walking out of class for months, partly in protest and partly to lobby for the bill. As the Globe reported:

“Over 17 minutes Wednesday morning, students from Somerville High School and other area schools orchestrated an old-fashioned phonebank blitz, flooding DeLeo’s office — and that of two other legislative leaders — with calls pushing what supporters call a “red flag” gun-control bill.”

None of the other proposals voters favor appear to be under serious consideration. With post-Parkland intensity beginning to fade, a red flag law may be the only change that passes for now. Sadly, given the rate of mass shootings, there is almost certain to be a call for more changes soon.


This has been an eventful week in Massachusetts politics, so much so that we released not one but two Horse Race podcasts this week. First was our regularly scheduled Wednesday programming, an in-depth look at this past weekend’s state Republican party convention.

Then on Thursday, Steve and Lauren made an emergency trip to the podcast bunker after former Senate President Stan Rosenberg yielded to pressure and resigned in the wake of the a scathing report about his handling of allegations against his husband.

Last week we did a deep dive on ranked choice voting, and then took a closer look at the money behind the ballot questions campaigns.


The FiveThirtyEight Trump approval tracker, which aggregates presidential approval polls, shows 41 percent approve of President Donald Trump’s job performance, and 53 percent disapprove. It has been very stable in this range in recent weeks.

Screenshot-2018-5-4 How Popular Is Donald Trump (1).png

Also from FiveThirtyEight, Democrats hold roughly a 7 point advantage in the generic congressional ballot, a lead which has remained in a fairly stable range.

A Monmouth poll finds just 17 percent approve of the job Congress is doing, continuing a long string of dismal reviews.

Pew finds a majority of Americans have confidence in the President on economic policy.

A new and way-too-early Suffolk University poll on the 2020 New Hampshire primary finds Elizabeth Warren running strongly against other would-be, might-be Democratic contenders. The poll could impact the attention she gets in her Senate race, but says little or nothing about who will be our next President.

A Quinnipiac poll finds that by a 51-37 margin, Republicans are more likely to say the news media is an enemy of the people rather than an important part of democracy. Most Americans (66 percent) disagree.

As the NRA meets in Dallas, Gallup offer ten takeaways from recent polling on guns.

Harry Enten, now at CNN, reviews the midterms polling so far, and says it’s been pretty accurate.

Western New England University released a too-rare poll of residents of Springfield. It found residents feeling bullish about the future, especially those that support the new casino opening this summer.

Morning Consult surveyed Americans about their favorite brands. Turns out Republicans and Democrats agree on something: Levis.

--------------------- Nerd Alert Tearline -------------------

It’s AAPOR time again next week, and Steve’s off to Denver for the nerdiest gathering of survey nerds anywhere. He’s got his pocket protector and his graphing calculator.

The official conference tee shirt slogan? “We have good surveys. The best surveys. No one is better at surveys than we are.”

Seriously, it’s good to be among fellow pollsters, but yeah, it’s nerdy. There’s even a talent show with titles like “Leveraging a more nuanced understanding of trust in survey research.” And the annual “applied probability” tournament -- or poker, for lay people.

PS: May the Fourth be With You!